Environmental, economic, and energetic costs and benefits. In this paper, we estimate what the price of corn would have been if no growth in corn. Economic impacts of the ethanol industry chad hart, daniel otto, and michael hudak the ethanol industry has transformed iowa over the past four decades. Ethanol is a domestically produced alternative fuel most commonly made from corn. Energy inputs used in production of corn are derived from the response of corn farmers in nine states for a survey on corn production practices and costs as part of the 2010 arms. Repowering assistance program convert heat andor power from fossil fuel to renewable biomass power. Policies aimed at conserving energy support energy independence, reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and benefit consumers. Currently, corn is the primary feedstock being used in the production process. Results indicate that increased corn ethanol production had a positive effect on net farm income and. Second generation ethanol from cellulosic biomass is around 7% of the total ethanol production.
The analysis shows that rotating alfalfa into a continuous corn system would increase the efficiency of energy production by about economics and energy of ethanol production from. Lignocellulosic biomass to ethanol process design and. Starting with some entrepreneurs in the 1970s and 1980s, ethanols growth has been tied to the iowa countryside and, more directly, to. Department of agriculture usda, and louisiana state university lsu. Even with all of these advantages, sugarcane ethanol projects have struggled to gain a foothold in the u. Most of the us production of ethanol is from starch, and almost all of the starchbased ethanol is made from corn grown in midwest states. The changing economics of corn ethanol agricultural. Likely remedies to achieve energy independence and reduce global warming include energy conservation, plugin hybrid technologies, and renewable fuels national research council, 1992.
The economic feasibility of ethanol production from sugar in the united states july 2006 this report was done through a cooperative agreement between the office of energy policy and new uses oepnu, office of the chief economist oce, u. Future capital costs will likely range from 19 cents. Corn cobs were found to yield higher glucose concentrations than other corn residues like. Corn ethanol process and production economics presented to the 2007 fertilizer outlook and technology conference arlington, va november 8, 2006 john m. Department of agricultural economics and agribusiness, 217 agriculture. October 24th, 2016 only facilities in operation prior to june 18, 2008 are eligible. Hence, the primary consequence of an increase in the demand for ethanol as a gasoline fuel additive is an increase in the demand for corn. Highlights graphica summary of biological processes to produce. Ethanol production starchbased ethanol production wet mill process flow diagram corn steep starch conversion germ separation starchgluten separation grind, screen fermentation oil refining germ fiber gluten th syrup refining downstream separations starch drying corn oil feed products starch sweeteners ethanol, chemicals. In this work, the key role that process design plays. According to ethanol reshapes the corn market, one 56pound bushel of corn will yield up to 2. The corn energy input for ethanol production declined to 9,007 btugal from 9,812 over the most recent 5year period, an 8. Henry ford and alexander graham bell were among the first to recognize that the plentiful sugars found in plants could be easily and inexpensively converted into cleanburning, renewable alcohol fuels.
Determining the cost of producing ethanol from corn starch. Wetmilling and dry grind are the two main conventional processes used for ethanol production from corn. Ethanol production using corn, switchgrass, and wood. However, the ddgs can be sold, so a credit is applied for that. The links between ethanol production consumption and various sectors of the economy are illustrated in figure 1. Introduction the corn drygrind process is the most widely used method in the u. The production of ethanol from starch or sugarbased crops is among mans earliest ventures into valueadded agriculturebased processing.
I found multiple references for all of the numbers i am going to use, but i will only reference a single source. The major cost in producing ethanol from corn is the cost of the feedstock itself. It is debatable whether the production and use of corn ethanol results in lower greenhouse gas emissions than gasoline. The economic feasibility of ethanol production in the eu from sugar beets is highly dependent on the negotiated price for sugar beets. Further, only the starch fraction of the corn kernel 66 percent is used for ethanol production. Lignocellulosic biomass to ethanol process design and economics utilizing cocurrent dilute acid prehydrolysis and enzymatic hydrolysis for corn stover. The economics of ethanol, agriculture and food ourenergypolicy. Ethanol production and safetyethanol production and safety. A global multicommodity simulation model was developed to estimate the impact of changes in ethanol production on the u. Current fuel ethanol research and development deals with process engineering trends for improving biotechnological production of ethanol. An economic analysis of cornbased ethanol production. Since 1980, the net cost of corn has ranged from under 10 cents to over 70 cents per gallon of ethanol produced.
Ethanol is the primary biofuel produced in the united states, with cornbased ethanol comprising more than 90 percent of domestic ethanol production u. Incoming corn is tested for moisture content, presence of insects, broken kernels and presence of fungi aspergillus niger. Production costs will be less for alfalfacorn than continuous corn, but profits may also be less. In contrast, support for corn ethanol production raises world commodity prices and pressures the land and water base, as occurred in the u. The policy analysis system simulation model was used to simulate alternative ethanol production scenarios for 2007 through 2016. Ethanol production for the week ending december 30 set a new ethanol production record with an average of 1. Ethanol is the primary biofuel produced in the united states, with corn based ethanol comprising more than 90 percent of domestic ethanol production u. Summary of estimated ethanol production costs dollars per gallon 1 cost item u. Comparison of ethanol production from corn cobs and. About 40% of total corn produced in united states is used for ethanol production. Corn ethanol is ethanol produced from corn biomass and is the main source of ethanol fuel in the united states. It is also made from cellulosic feedstocks, such as crop residues and woodthough this is not as common. Pdf economics and energy of ethanol production from alfalfa. Environmental, economic, and energetic costs and benefits of.
The ability to produce ethanol from lowcost biomass will be key. Pdf economics and energy of ethanol production from. The additional utilization of plant residues such as corn cobs or stover can potentially increase the ethanol yield per unit area and utilize existing conversion and distribution infrastructure. The renewable fuel standard in competitive equilibrium. Environmental benefits of oxygenated containing oxygen fuels, such as an ethanolgasoline blend, include reducing carbon monoxide emissions from automobiles.
This study evaluated the impacts of increased ethanol production from corn starch on agricultural land use and the environment in the united states. Environmental benefits of oxygenated containing oxygen fuels, such as an ethanol gasoline blend, include reducing carbon monoxide emissions from automobiles. Some states also have a state subsidy for ethanol production. Mar 26, 2020 assuming that production of each gallon of ethanol is associated with 5. It is certainly possible that some of the early practitioners of this new technology will be the current corn ethanol producers. The mature corn to ethanol industry has many similarities to the emerging lignocelluloseto ethanol industry. The longrun and shortrun effects of ethanol production on u. Corn to ethanol conversion is the most mature technology. Trees and grasses have much of their sugars locked up in a fibrous material called cellulose, which can be broken down into sugars and made into ethanol. Ethanol production and exports returned strong numbers over.
The production of ethanol from corn is a mature technology that is not likely to see significant reductions in production costs. In this article, therefore, we develop a structural model of ethanol production from corn and biodiesel production from soybean oil. Ethanol production an overview sciencedirect topics. The most widely discussed issue related to the increased production of ethanol is the impact of ethanol production on the price of cornbased food. Environmental challenges associated with corn ethanol production. Ethanol production and exports returned strong numbers over the. Economics and energy of ethanol production from alfalfa. Economics and energy of ethanol production from alfalfa, corn, and switchgrass in the upper midwest, usa. Jiaoqi gao, wenjie yuan, in advances in feedstock conversion technologies for.
Determining the cost of producing ethanol from corn starch nrel. These benefits have led several states to develop oxygenated fuel programs. The links between ethanol productionconsumption and various sectors of the economy are illustrated in figure 1. The mature corntoethanol industry has many similarities to the emerging lignocellulosetoethanol industry. Presently, ethanol production in the united states and canada is predominately derived from corn grains. Corn ethanol is produced by ethanol fermentation and distillation. Ethanol yields 25% more energy than the energy invested in its production, whereas biodiesel yields 93% more. Economic and environmental impacts of the corn grain. In addition to the effect on food prices, it has been argued that. Economics of ethanol production in the united states naldc usda.
It typically takes about 30 cubic feet of natural gas to produce a gallon of cornethanol. But, the paper concludes, cornbased ethanol production has strong political support effectively influencing carbon regulation in a manner consistent with private interest. The single greatest cost in the production of ethanol from corn, and the cost with the greatest variability, is the cost of the corn. Pdf bioethanol has recently emerged as a major issue in energy policy to fulfill growing energy demand and sustainable economy. Economics and energy of ethanol production from alfalfa, corn. The effect of the us ethanol mandate on corn prices. Environmental challenges associated with corn ethanol. Declining natural gas price since 2007 has resulted in a reduction in the cost of natural gas for cornethanol production.
Economic and environmental impacts of the corn grain ethanol. Pretreatment in dry grind corn process involves quality testing, storage, cleaning, removal of stones and metal debris. Assuming that production of each gallon of ethanol is associated with 5. The model captures the competition of primary agricultural products for scarce land. Nebraska currently has 25 ethanol plants producing around 2 billion gallons of ethanol annually. Urbanchuk director, lecg llc 1255 drummers lane, suite 320 wayne, pa 19087 tel. With the federal government mandating a fivefold increase in ethanol production by 2022, it seems inevitable that an increasing share of the nations corn crop will be devoted to ethanol production. There are a variety of costs other than corn associated with cornethanol production. Production capacity across the country is expected to. This represents about 75 million bushels of corn, and this could offset some of the lost corn demand associated with lower ethanol production and. Currently, the main sources of biofuel production are corn. Atiyeh department of biosystems and agricultural engineering, oklahoma state university, stillwater, ok 74078, usa. In this paper, we estimate what the price of corn would have been if no growth in. Farming for fuel is a relatively new concept for u.
Pdf the production of fuel ethanol from corn grain is widely carried out in the us. Modeling the process and costs of fuel ethanol production by. Results indicate that increased corn ethanol production had a positive effect on net farm income and economic. The accumulated effects of corn ethanol production on corn prices and the ways in which these effects influence a farmers decisions about crop choices for. The coronavirus and ethanol demand destruction farmdoc daily. The major feedstock for ethanol has been coarse grains i. Modeling the process and costs of fuel ethanol production.
Increased ethanol production under the energy acts of 2005 and 2007 resulted in a significant increase in the price of corn. Effect of changing feedstock cost on fuel ethanol production cost. Ethanol production is being done from many sugar and starch crops, out of which maize plant seems to be commonly used. Biofuels include both ethanol corn and biodiesel soybean oil, but ethanol is far in the lead.
Prospects for corn consumption from ethanol production in. Another report notes that although the price increase cannot be blamed. The primary uses for corn in the state are cattle feed and ethanol production. Ethanol is blended in more than 97% of gasoline in the u. Dry mill ethanol plants are evolving and the processes are being revised with each new plant and retrofit. Corn is by far the largest feedstock in the production of ethanol. So the net corn energy used for ethanol production is 9,007 btugal in table 1b. Parts of the maize plant like its stalk, cobs, kernelsetc have been put to use for the extraction of ethanol. The most widely discussed issue related to the increased production of ethanol is the impact of ethanol production on the price of corn based food. The process of making corn into ethanol is a multistep process. Ethanol can be added to gasoline to boost the oxygen content. The subsidy rates on corn ethanol are quantified and compared relative to crude oil and the gasoline that can be derived from it along with the effects of corn ethanol on gasoline prices.
559 1398 913 1330 158 204 934 1566 353 1433 1519 1371 1506 1044 669 1430 1149 1534 394 163 1100 545 1451 55 192 354 435 337 802 1403 448 147 1456 1333 1236 1121